Skip to the news

Federal farm & food policy for producers, lenders and agribusiness

Commodity Hill

Federal agriculture and food policy, from the committee room to the field.

Specialty

EPA sets isocycloseram limit on sunflower seed after South Dakota's emergency weevil sprays; tolerance runs to 2029

A November 13 rule sets a 0.4 ppm residue limit for the new Group 30 insecticide on sunflower seed, backing a Section 18 exemption that let South Dakota growers spray Vertento against pyrethroid-resistant red sunflower seed weevil this summer. Objections are due January 12.

South Dakota sunflower growers could spray Vertento, Syngenta’s new isocycloseram insecticide, from July 15 to August 31 this year under an emergency exemption[5]. The federal residue limit covering that crop arrived on November 13, well after the last legal spray date: a 0.4 parts per million (ppm) tolerance on sunflower seed that stays on the books through December 31, 2029[1].

The Environmental Protection Agency issued the tolerance without notice and comment, as the food safety law allows for residues from emergency-exemption uses[1]. Anyone who wants to contest it has until January 12, 2027, to file objections[1].

What EPA’s November 13 rule does

The rule adds a new paragraph (b) to the isocycloseram tolerance section, 40 CFR 180.730, covering residues from use under Section 18 of the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), the emergency exemption provision[1]. It sets one entry: sunflower seed, 0.4 ppm, expiring 12/31/2029[1]. Compliance is measured on the parent compound alone[1].

The request came from South Dakota’s Department of Agriculture and Natural Resources (DANR), which, in EPA’s words, “utilized a specific exemption” to control red sunflower seed weevil[1]. DANR told EPA that widespread infestations had left growers without insecticides that fit integrated pest management in sunflowers, and that growers faced significant yield losses[1]. EPA found that an emergency existed and that the approval criteria were met[1].

On safety, EPA leaned on the toxicity work behind its November 20, 2025, isocycloseram tolerances and on a June 26, 2026, human health risk assessment written for the South Dakota request[1]. That assessment combined dietary, drinking water and residential exposure and, according to EPA, identified no risk estimates of concern[1]. The rule notes there are no Codex or Canadian maximum residue limits for isocycloseram on sunflowers[1].

The rule also limits itself. It says the tolerance is not a decision on whether isocycloseram meets registration standards for sunflowers, cannot support a state special local need registration under FIFRA section 24(c), and does not let anyone outside South Dakota use the product on sunflowers without a separate emergency exemption for their state[1]. Sunflower seed treated lawfully before the 2029 expiration can still be sold after that date if residues stay within 0.4 ppm[1].

How does a Section 18 exemption work?

EPA’s emergency exemption rules let a state agency ask for a “specific exemption” to avert a significant economic loss[4]. EPA must decide whether an emergency exists, whether it can set a time-limited tolerance, and what the benefits and risks are[4]. A specific exemption cannot last longer than one year[4]. A state that comes back the next season can re-certify that the prior year’s emergency continues, provided the conditions of use are unchanged and it knows of no workable alternative[4].

Isocycloseram has been through this before. In July 2025, months before the active ingredient was registered, EPA announced a New York request to use it on up to 2,500 acres of bulb onions against onion thrips, and skipped the comment period because of the timing[3]. EPA then set permanent isocycloseram tolerances on November 20, 2025, on a Syngenta petition covering field corn, soybeans, cottonseed, wheat, canola, bulb onions, tree nuts, citrus, vegetables and livestock commodities[2]. Sunflower was not on that list[2].

In the field: a product for pyrethroid-resistant weevils

The case for the exemption rests on resistance. SDSU Extension has confirmed red sunflower seed weevil resistance in South Dakota to five pyrethroids: lambda-cyhalothrin, esfenvalerate, cypermethrin, deltamethrin and beta-cyfluthrin[6]. It also received reports of malathion field failures in 2025[6]. Chlorpyrifos is out of the picture: SDSU’s 2026 research forum presentation said sunflower was not among the uses left after June 30, 2025, and that EPA had denied a 24(c) label for the weevil in South Dakota sunflowers[7].

Isocycloseram is an IRAC Group 30 insecticide with a different target site than pyrethroids or organophosphates[5, 6]. In a 2022 SDSU laboratory assay it killed 100% of a weevil population collected in Hughes County, and in field trials it “greatly reduced the percentage of damaged seeds” compared with untreated plots[6].

Field results have not all been that clean. In the 2025 efficacy study near Highmore, SDSU summarized its South Dakota findings as “Insecticides don’t look effective,” while planting date “still looks good”[7]. Plots planted June 3 yielded 748 pounds per acre and plots planted June 17 yielded 1,227 pounds[7].

The Section 18 label set tight terms[5]:

  • Rate: 1.6 to 2.0 fluid ounces per acre, with the higher rate under heavy pressure; no more than 4.0 fluid ounces per acre and two applications a year, at least 7 days apart.
  • Rotation: no more than one Vertento application before switching to a different mode of action.
  • Bloom: no foliar application from the onset of flowering until flowering ends, unless sprayed before 10 a.m., after 3 p.m., or at 50°F or cooler.
  • Drift and runoff: wind-directional buffers of 300 feet by air and 25 feet by ground, a Bulletins Live! Two check within six months of application, and two runoff mitigation points outside pesticide use limitation areas.
  • Harvest and grazing: a 14-day preharvest interval and no grazing of treated fields.

The label also told applicators that ground rigs give better control than aircraft, and to avoid oil-based adjuvants during flowering because they can cause floret abortion[5]. SDSU advised a single application of either Vertento or malathion, rotating to the other product if a second spray is needed, and recommended against tank mixes even though the label allows them[6].

North Dakota’s question for 2027

The exemption stopped at the state line. The Red River Farm Network reported in July that the North Dakota Department of Agriculture was working with EPA on whether the state could be added[8]. NDSU Extension said the same week that it had detected reduced susceptibility to deltamethrin and lambda-cyhalothrin in southwestern North Dakota weevil populations in 2025[9].

By mid-August the pressure was visible in NDSU’s scouting. Weevil populations rose fourfold in a week, the share of infested fields went from 29% to 63%, and about 26% of fields scouted were above the 5-weevils-per-head economic threshold[10]. Growers in southwestern and south-central North Dakota reported pyrethroid control of only 50% to 60%[10]. NDSU Extension’s Janet Knodel asked for field failure reports to support “a possible Section 18” for Vertento in North Dakota sunflowers in 2027[10].

NDSU’s 2026 thresholds give a sense of the economics. For oilseed sunflowers at 28 cents a pound and 16,000 to 25,000 plants per acre, the threshold runs from more than 5 to 8 weevils per head with a $6 insecticide and $12 aerial application, and more than 6 to 9 weevils with an $8 insecticide[10]. For confection sunflowers it is more than 1 to 2 weevils per head[10].

John Sandbakken, executive director of the National Sunflower Association, put the industry’s interest this way: “We want to make sure we stay ahead of the seed weevils so they don’t become resistant to other products”[8].

What to watch

  • January 12, 2027: deadline for objections and hearing requests on the sunflower tolerance, filed with EPA’s Hearing Clerk under 40 CFR part 178 and referencing docket EPA-HQ-OPP-2026-5678[1].
  • A 2027 South Dakota request. The tolerance runs through 2029, but any 2027 spraying needs a new or re-certified exemption, since each specific exemption lasts at most a year[1, 4].
  • North Dakota. Whether the state files for 2027, and whether EPA treats reduced pyrethroid susceptibility there as an emergency, is still open[9, 10].
  • Registration. A permanent sunflower use would require a regular registration decision, which EPA says it has not made[1].