Skip to the news

Federal farm & food policy for producers, lenders and agribusiness

Commodity Hill

Federal agriculture and food policy, from the committee room to the field.

Specialty

RMA withdraws five-year-old apple policy rewrite; fresh fruit factor and slicer change will not be finalized

A November 13 notice formally drops the December 2021 proposal that would have counted below-Fancy apples against Quality Option claims and stopped counting slicer sales as fresh. Any new attempt would start with a new proposed rule.

The Federal Crop Insurance Corporation (FCIC), whose programs the Risk Management Agency (RMA) administers, says rewriting the apple policy is “not necessary or appropriate at this time”[1, 8]. With that line, in a one-page notice published November 13, FCIC withdrew the apple crop insurance overhaul it proposed in December 2021, ending a rulemaking that apple growers had commented on, attended listening sessions about and waited on for nearly five years[1, 2].

The withdrawal took effect on publication[1]. FCIC said it no longer intends to issue a final rule and that, if it decides to try again, it will publish a new proposed rule[1].

What the withdrawal notice says

The notice is brief. It recites that the 2021 proposal was meant to better meet apple producers’ needs, to address “program vulnerabilities that have caused increased loss ratios and rising premium costs,” and to guard against fraud, waste and abuse[1]. After a 60-day comment period, a 60-day extension requested by stakeholders and “multiple rounds of listening sessions nationwide,” FCIC concluded, “based on the public comments and additional feedback, that the proposed changes would not have had the intended effect”[1].

The notice does not say which provisions drew the objections, and it does not describe a replacement[1]. It was signed by Patricia Swanson, the FCIC manager[1].

What the 2021 proposal would have changed

The December 16, 2021, proposal ran 11 Federal Register pages and was written to take effect for the 2023 crop year[2]. Its center was the Optional Coverage for Fresh Fruit Quality Adjustment, the Quality Option, which pays when fresh apple production fails to grade U.S. Fancy or better because of an insured cause of loss[2].

FCIC wrote that the option’s high loss ratios came from producers’ inability to keep the records needed to qualify and settle claims, and from climates in some regions that make it hard to produce U.S. Fancy fruit consistently[2]. Its fixes, now dropped, included:

  • A fresh fruit factor. Apples grading U.S. No. 1 Processing or better but below U.S. Fancy, which under the current option are not counted in claims, would have counted at a reduced value set by a regional factor in the actuarial documents[2, 6]. FCIC said the existing rule let a producer “double-dip” on indemnity and sales from the same apples[2].
  • A linear sliding scale. Quality adjustment under the current scale starts at 21% damage and reaches zero at 65%, in three uneven steps; the proposal would have started at 15% and cut production to count by 2% for each full percentage point above that[2].
  • Slicers and hard cider. Apples sold for slicing or hard cider would no longer count as fresh production, or toward the one-in-four-years fresh-sales test, unless sold as U.S. Fancy or better[2]. FCIC cited a contracted study finding that slicer prices track processing prices more closely than fresh[2].
  • An Apple Supplemental Report. Growers insuring fresh acreage would have reported production by fresh and processing sales, and revenue too if they wanted the new premium price election[2].

Some of the dropped provisions cut the other way. The proposal would have let growers pick separate coverage levels and price election percentages for each fresh type, such as 90% coverage on varietal group A and 70% on group B[2]. It offered a premium price election, above the published price, for apples sold mostly to direct markets or premium processors; FCIC said slicers bring about 20% more than standard processing prices on average[2]. It would also have let growers file a revised acreage report by March 31 to cut premium on trees grafted or removed after the January 15 acreage reporting date[2]. Basin Business Journal’s January 2022 summary began with the coverage-level choices and the grafting premium cut[4].

In the orchard: what stays the same

For growers, the practical result is no change. The Quality Option, the current sliding scale and the existing fresh-sales test stay as they are, and none of the 2021 additions arrive[1, 2]. RMA’s July 2026 freeze bulletin cites the policy in force as Apple Crop Provisions (11-0054)[10].

The fight over the proposal was regional. In July 2023, 24 New England senators and House members, among them Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, Sen. Susan Collins and Rep. Rosa DeLauro, wrote RMA that most of the region’s orchards are small, family-owned and sell fresh apples locally, often without nearby processing capacity[5]. They warned that changes to the Quality Option “may severely impact producers who disproportionately rely on fresh fruit sales,” that the new reporting could be “overly burdensome” for the smallest producers, and that adverse changes “may compel New England growers to forgo insurance coverage altogether”[5].

RMA’s case rested on loss experience concentrated in other places. Farm Credit East, the Northeast farm lender, reported in October 2023 that the apple policy insured more than 240,000 acres with about $2.1 billion in protection, and that indemnities since 2012 had topped $1.1 billion against more than $467 million in producer-paid premiums[6]. For 2012 through 2016 the all-states loss ratio was 0.95, while New York’s was 1.96[6].

By then RMA had softened the plan. Farm Credit East wrote that after the 2023 listening sessions the fresh fruit factor would be capped at 10% in the policy’s first year, fruit sold without a grade would count as full production rather than face the factor, and the revised policy was planned for 2025[6]. The draft had drawn more than 1,000 comments from over 200 commenters, by Farm Credit East’s count[6].

For a sense of what growers pay today, RMA’s August 2024 fact sheet lists a 55% premium subsidy at the 75% coverage level on basic units, a $655 administrative fee per crop per county for catastrophic coverage, and insurability thresholds of 150 bushels per acre in most eastern states, 200 bushels in Colorado and 10 bins in the West[11]. Acreage reports are due January 15 everywhere but California, where the date is March 15[11].

How did the apple rule stall?

The timeline explains much of the withdrawal. RMA pushed comments to April 15, 2022[3]. On February 20, 2024, it said it would postpone a final rule for the 2025 crop year and gather more feedback before acting[7]. No final rule followed.

Then the legal ground moved. An FCIC rule effective May 1, 2026, removed federal crop insurance policy provisions, the apple provisions among them, from the Code of Federal Regulations[8]. FCIC said individual crop policies “function as contracts rather than legislative rules” and that their terms would be published through program materials and the RMA website instead[8]. That rule said it changed only where policy text is printed, not coverage or producer obligations[8]. The withdrawal notice does not mention it, and does not say whether future apple changes would go through rulemaking at all; it says only that FCIC would act “consistent with the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act, as applicable”[1].

On the Hill and in the field offices

The 2026 season gave RMA a different apple problem. After a late-April freeze, the agency issued emergency procedures letting insurers finalize Quality Option claims in Maryland, Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, Virginia and West Virginia before growers sold the crop, on a signed promise to report harvested production within 30 days[9, 10]. “RMA listened to apple growers and the crop insurance industry, and we responded with a commonsense approach,” Swanson said in July[9]. Claims under that bulletin turn on section 14(b)(5) of the apple policy, the same Quality Option paragraph the 2021 proposal would have rewritten[2, 10].

The record this piece draws on shows no pending congressional action specific to the apple policy.

What to watch

  • A new apple proposal. FCIC says any future regulatory action would start fresh with a new proposed rule or other issuance[1]. None is scheduled in the notice.
  • How policy changes are made now. With crop provisions out of the CFR since May 1, 2026, it is an open question whether a future apple revision would carry a public comment period like the one in 2021[1, 8].
  • December 31, 2026. The disposal date for RMA’s April-freeze apple bulletin, MGR-26-006.2[10].