Court gives Labor until Dec. 30 to replace H-2A wage rule; growers face backpay exposure dating to Sept. 2
A federal judge in Fresno vacates the 2025 Adverse Effect Wage Rate method on Dec. 30 and has ordered a new interim rule by then. Whatever rates it produces will decide whether growers owe workers the difference for fall and winter payrolls.
What will an H-2A worker cost a grower on December 31? Nobody can say yet, and a federal judge in Fresno has set the date by which the Labor Department must answer. By court order, the department has until December 30, 2026 to issue a new interim final rule setting the Adverse Effect Wage Rate (AEWR), the minimum hourly wage for H-2A guestworkers, and the 2025 rule now in force is vacated that same day[2]. Employers who have kept H-2A crews on payroll since September 2 could owe those workers the difference if the new rates come in higher[5].
What the court ordered
The case is United Farm Workers v. U.S. Department of Labor, No. 1:25-cv-01614 in the Eastern District of California[1]. On August 26 the court held unlawful the department’s interim final rule of October 2, 2025, published at 90 FR 47914, which sets AEWRs for non-range farm jobs[1]. The court found the rule both arbitrary and capricious and procedurally defective under the Administrative Procedure Act[2].
Four parts of the 2025 method were challenged, and the court took them one at a time[1]:
- Two wage tiers. The rule split jobs into an entry-level Skill Level I, priced at about the 17th percentile of the occupational wage distribution, and an experienced Skill Level II at the 50th percentile[1]. The rule itself estimated that 92% of H-2A positions would land in the lower tier[1]. The court said that a 17th-percentile wage paid to 92% of workers was not explained as a “market-based” wage[1].
- The housing adjustment. Employers must still provide free housing to H-2A workers and to U.S. workers in corresponding employment who cannot go home each night[1]. The rule cut the hourly AEWR to offset that housing, for H-2A workers only[1]. The court called it arbitrary and capricious “for three independent reasons,” among them that it conflicts with the no-cost housing requirement at 20 CFR 655.122(d)(1), and that a deduction computed on a 40-hour week but taken from every hour worked leaves workers on longer weeks paying more than the housing is worth[1].
- The data source. USDA discontinued its Farm Labor Survey in August 2025, and the department switched to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) survey[1]. The OEWS does not capture farm establishments; the rule relied on it largely because it surveys farm labor contractors[1]. The court faulted the department for not weighing adjustments to that data; the department acknowledged at oral argument that contractor-employed farmworkers typically earn less[1].
- The “greater than 50%” rule. A job is classed under whichever occupation code covers the majority of the worker’s time[1].
The court did not vacate the rule in August, citing “the significant disruption that might attend vacating the IFR immediately,” and instead ordered the department to “promptly produce a new methodology”[1].
How the Dec. 30 deadline came about
The department first told the court, on September 9, that it would replace the method only through a new final rule, which it said would take another nine to twelve months[2]. The court said a further year-long delay was not warranted[2]. On September 28 the department switched course and agreed to write a second interim rule, which it called “IFR II,” but estimated it would need up to six months from October 1[3]. It cited two steps it cannot skip: approval by the Secretary of Homeland Security after consultation with the Labor and Agriculture secretaries, which section 301(e) of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 requires for H-2A regulations, and review by the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs[3].
The union’s lawyers asked for an interim rule within three weeks[2]. The court split the difference on October 2. It noted that after a Louisiana court vacated the 2023 wage rule on August 25, 2025, the department had issued the current rule five and a half weeks later[2]. “Defendants have not shown why it would require over three times as long to issue a new interim final rule as it took to issue the current IFR,” the order reads[2]. It set December 30 for the new rule and the vacatur, with joint status reports every three weeks until the rule issues[2].
In the October 22 report, the department said it “respectfully maintains its objection” to a date-certain deadline but is working toward issuing the new rule by December 30[4]. It reported drafting the preamble and regulatory text, evaluating alternative data, and opening the consultation with Homeland Security and USDA[4]. The union said it understood the department did not anticipate any issue in meeting the deadline[4]. It added that once the rule is out, the parties may litigate whether it squares with the August ruling, and that it will seek a backpay order[4].
In the field: payroll since Sept. 2 is the exposure
For growers, the rates on the books today stay in force for now. The department’s September 2 notice says “the current AEWRs will remain in effect until the publication of new AEWRs”[5]. Those are the rates published August 3, effective that day in most states and August 17 for entities and states covered by the Kansas v. U.S. Department of Labor order[6].
For the combined field and livestock worker group, the entry-level rate runs from $8.84 an hour in Mississippi to $14.91 in Nebraska; the experienced rate runs from $13.41 in Florida to $19.22 in Nebraska[7]. The American Farm Bureau Federation put the national average Skill Level I rate at $12.31, up 3.5% from the prior year, and Skill Level II at $16.07, up 2.1%[8]. Kansas saw the steepest entry-level jump, 21.3%, to $13.86[8]. The housing adjustment under the 2025 method may not exceed 30% of the hourly AEWR[7].
The backpay question is where the money sits. At the court’s direction, the department told employers that those who used H-2A labor under the 2025 rates between September 2, 2026 and the issuance of a new method “may be required to make wage adjustment payments” to qualifying H-2A workers and U.S. workers in corresponding employment, if those workers were paid below the new rates[5]. The department was explicit that “no employer is under an obligation at this time to pay any back wages”[5]. The court reserved whether backpay should be awarded, and in what amount, until new rates exist[1]. The union has asked for backpay only for this remand period, not for the full life of the 2025 rule[1].
How the exposure breaks down by operation, as the sources support it:
- Fruit, vegetable, nursery and specialty crop growers count wages among their largest costs, and the uncertainty is already complicating crop budgets, Southeast AgNet reported[9]. Chris Butts of the Georgia Fruit and Vegetable Growers Association told Specialty Crop Grower that growers cannot currently predict their wage rates, and advised: “Take a deep breath. Nothing happens immediately”[10].
- Livestock and dairy employers with H-2A animal workers fall in the same combined field and livestock group, so the same rates and the same backpay notice apply[7, 5].
- Sheep and goat ranchers using range herders are outside this case. Range jobs use a separate national monthly AEWR, $2,132.41 effective February 3, 2026[7].
The department’s notice reminds employers to keep current records of workers’ names, addresses, Social Security numbers if issued, and other contact information[5]. Fisher & Phillips, a management-side firm, noted that the 2025 rule is the third version of the wage method in 12 months and that the department now has to write a fourth[11].
On the Hill
USDA has a formal seat in the rewrite. The Agriculture secretary is a statutory consultant on H-2A regulations[3], and the Labor Department reported opening that consultation with USDA and Homeland Security in October[4].
Grower groups want Congress to settle the method instead. “Today’s decision is a reminder that lasting reform cannot come through regulation alone,” Jamie Fussell, director of labor relations at the Florida Fruit & Vegetable Association, said after the August ruling; he added that “Congress must act with urgency”[9]. The association pointed to the Securing Agriculture’s Workforce Act, or SAWA, as a longer-term fix[9]. The Farm Bureau has estimated that a proposed SAWA cap on year-over-year increases would have held Louisiana’s entry-level increase to 27 cents an hour instead of 90 cents, a difference of nearly $8.5 million in wage costs in that state[8].
The union and its farmworker plaintiffs see it the other way: the problem is a method that set wages too low. The statute bars H-2A hiring that will “adversely affect the wages and working conditions” of U.S. workers, and the court found that in building the housing adjustment the department “failed to reasonably consider” whether it could meet that obligation[1]. The department has said that complying with the order does not waive its right to seek further review[5].
What to watch
- December 30, 2026: Deadline for the new interim final rule, and the date the 2025 rule is vacated[2].
- Joint status reports on the court’s three-week cycle; the union said the next was due November 12[2, 4].
- New AEWRs: The court will then set supplemental briefing on whether growers owe backpay for work since September 2, and how much[1, 5].
- A fight over the new rule itself: The union has said it may challenge whether the replacement complies with the August order[4].