Skip to the news

Federal farm & food policy for producers, lenders and agribusiness

Commodity Hill

Federal agriculture and food policy, from the committee room to the field.

Specialty

EPA makes metamitron sugar beet tolerance permanent; Goltix registration for Palmer amaranth still pending

A November 20 rule sets a permanent 0.01 ppm residue limit for metamitron on sugar beet roots and retires the emergency-use tolerance that ran to 2027. The herbicide is still sold to beet growers only under state-by-state Section 18 exemptions. Objections are due January 19.

The Goltix 700 SC label that western beet growers worked from this spring opens with a warning: “UNREGISTERED PRODUCT. FOR EMERGENCY EXEMPTION USE ONLY”[8]. A rule published November 20 removes one of the two regulatory gaps behind that warning. The Environmental Protection Agency set a permanent tolerance of 0.01 parts per million (ppm) for the herbicide metamitron in or on sugar beet roots, effective the same day[1].

The other gap is still open. A tolerance governs how much residue may legally remain on the harvested crop. It does not authorize anyone to sell or apply the product. ADAMA’s applications to register metamitron for use on sugar beets have been at EPA since June 2025[6], and the record shows no decision on them.

What the November 20 rule does

The rule amends 40 CFR 180.726 in two ways[1]. It adds “Beet, sugar, roots” at 0.01 ppm to the permanent tolerance table in paragraph (a), alongside the apple and pear tolerances already there[1, 7]. It also removes and reserves paragraph (b), the time-limited tolerance EPA created in July 2024 to cover residues from emergency use[1]. That earlier tolerance, also 0.01 ppm, was written to expire December 31, 2027[2].

The action answers pesticide petition PP 5F9188, filed by ADAMA Agan Ltd. through its U.S. arm, Makhteshim Agan of North America[1]. EPA announced the petition December 1, 2025 and received one comment, which it classed as non-substantive[1]. Charles Smith, director of the Registration Division in EPA’s Office of Pesticide Programs, signed the rule November 12[1].

EPA’s safety finding leans on earlier work. The agency did not reprint its toxicology review and instead pointed to the March 2025 apple and pear rule and the July 2024 emergency tolerance[1]. It did update one input. The estimated drinking water concentrations now used for metamitron are 232 parts per billion for acute exposure and 127 parts per billion for chronic exposure[1]. In the March 2025 rule, EPA had used sugar beet surface-water estimates of 91 and 61 parts per billion as its high-end figures[3]. Even with the higher inputs, EPA put acute dietary exposure at 4.1% of the acceptable level for the general population and 14% for infants, the most exposed group, with chronic exposure at 2.9% and 11%[1]. The Codex Alimentarius has no maximum residue limit for metamitron on sugar beets, so EPA said harmonization was not an issue[1].

How did metamitron reach sugar beets without a registration?

Through Section 18 of the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), which lets EPA exempt a state agency from the act’s requirements when emergency conditions exist[10]. When EPA allows emergency use on a food crop, the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act requires a matching time-limited tolerance[2, 11].

Colorado and Nebraska asked first. EPA granted both states exemptions for metamitron on sugar beets against Palmer amaranth that registered herbicides were not controlling, and set the 2024 time-limited tolerance to cover them[2]. In that rule EPA said it had made no decision on whether metamitron met the standards for registration on sugar beets, or whether a permanent tolerance would be appropriate[2].

For 2025, five state departments of agriculture asked for up to 116,902 acres: 22,468 in Colorado, 14,400 in Idaho, 47,025 in Nebraska, 1,629 in Oregon and 31,380 in Wyoming[4]. Because metamitron was then an unregistered active ingredient, EPA took public comment first[4]. It received 11 comments, 10 in favor and one objecting, and authorized all five states on December 17, 2024 for use from March 30 through June 15, 2025[5]. The agency said it found no risks of concern and that significant economic losses were expected without the herbicide[5].

Metamitron’s first permanent food tolerances came in between, on apples and pears in March 2025[3]. By December 2025, EPA was listing the sugar beet applications among new uses of currently registered active ingredients[6].

The 2026 exemptions followed the same five states. The Section 18 label lists exemption numbers 26ID01, 26OR01, 26CO01, 26NE01 and 26WY01[8].

In the beet field: rate, counties and limits

The 2026 label restricts use to named counties[8]:

  • Colorado: Adams, Boulder, Larimer, Logan, Morgan, Phillips, Sedgewick, Washington, Weld and Yuma
  • Idaho: Canyon, Cassia, Elmore, Gooding, Jerome, Minidoka, Owyhee and Payette
  • Nebraska: Banner, Box Butte, Chase, Cheyenne, Dawes, Deuel, Garden, Keith, Kimball, Morrill, Perkins, Scotts Bluff, Sheridan and Sioux
  • Oregon: Malheur
  • Wyoming: Big Horn, Fremont, Goshen, Laramie, Park, Platte and Washakie

Use windows ran March 20 to June 15 in Idaho and Oregon, March 30 to June 15 in Colorado, and April 1 to May 15 in Nebraska and Wyoming[8]. Unused product had to go back to a retailer or distributor after the season[8].

The label calls for a single pre-emergence ground application at 64 fluid ounces of product per acre, or 2.92 pounds of active ingredient, in at least 10 gallons of water[8]. It must be incorporated with a quarter to a half inch of rain or irrigation within 48 hours[8]. A second application is allowed only on a replanted stand, no sooner than 20 days after the first[8]. Aerial application and application through irrigation systems are prohibited, rotational crops cannot go in for 30 days, and growers must earn at least three points from EPA’s runoff mitigation menu[8]. The label also recommends a Group 15 herbicide at the two-true-leaf stage, since metamitron is a pre-emergence tool[8].

The label carries a groundwater advisory: metamitron has properties associated with chemicals detected in groundwater, and may leach where soils are permeable and the water table is shallow[8]. Fields next to lakes, rivers or permanent streams may be treated only in alternate years, with a 100-foot ground-application setback[8].

Growers’ stake in this is documented. The University of Nebraska–Lincoln reported in April that U.S. Department of Agriculture data show yield losses of 30% or more from uncontrolled Palmer amaranth in Nebraska and Colorado, with some test sites reaching 47%[9]. Rebecca Larson, chief scientist at Western Sugar Cooperative, told the university that about half the co-op’s members used Goltix in 2024, adding more than $8 million in revenue[9]. Nevin Lawrence, the Scottsbluff weed scientist whose trials backed the state requests, described the case he made to EPA: “My work on Goltix showed it was effective, and my other work in sugar beet showed that there was no other option”[9]. The university also noted that EPA initially had only European Union regulatory data on the product[9].

Section 18 use is also narrower than registered use. The label covers glyphosate-tolerant Palmer amaranth in the listed counties only[8]. Growers outside those five states, or targeting other weeds, have no authorization under it[8]. EPA said in 2024 that the emergency tolerance could not support a state special local need registration under FIFRA section 24(c)[2].

On the docket: what EPA still has to decide

The registration applications are the decision that matters for 2027 planting. EPA’s December 2025 notice listed two ADAMA metamitron applications for the proposed use “Beet, sugar, roots,” both received June 10, 2025: an amendment to EPA Reg. No. 11603-63 and a new product under File Symbol 66222-GRA, both in docket EPA-HQ-OPP-2025-1444[6]. Comments on those applications closed December 31, 2025[6]. EPA said some registration actions get a second comment period on a proposed decision[6]. The tolerance rule says nothing about timing[1].

Commodity Hill covered the same Section 18 sequence for a new insecticide on sunflowers last week, in earlier coverage. The metamitron case is a step further along: the residue limit is no longer tied to an emergency.

Opposition in the record is thin. The one objecting comment on the 2025 exemptions is noted by EPA without detail[5], and the one comment on the tolerance petition was non-substantive[1].

What to watch

  • January 19, 2027: Deadline for objections and hearing requests on the tolerance, filed with EPA’s Hearing Clerk under docket EPA-HQ-OPP-2025-1444[1].
  • EPA registration decision: No date announced on Reg. No. 11603-63 or File Symbol 66222-GRA[6]. Without a registration before spring, beet states would need fresh Section 18 exemptions to use metamitron in 2027[10].
  • 2027 exemption requests: The 2026 Nebraska and Wyoming windows opened April 1[8]. Whether Colorado, Idaho, Nebraska, Oregon and Wyoming file again depends on what EPA does with the registration first, and neither EPA nor the states have said in the record which comes first.