Skip to the news

Federal farm & food policy for producers, lenders and agribusiness

Commodity Hill

Federal agriculture and food policy, from the committee room to the field.

Specialty

APHIS draft CWD standards cut whitetail quarantine to 4 years, tie indemnity to genetics; comments now due Dec. 28

A revised Chronic Wasting Disease Herd Certification Program Standards draft would shorten trace and quarantine periods for white-tailed and mule deer, keep five years for elk, and rank indemnity requests partly on genetic scores. APHIS has extended comments from November 25 to December 28.

Under the standards farmed cervid owners work under now, a deer herd that was not depopulated after a chronic wasting disease (CWD) exposure stays quarantined for 60 months[5]. A draft from the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) would cut that to four years for white-tailed deer and three for mule deer, while keeping five years for elk, red deer and other susceptible species[3]. APHIS has given producers, states and wildlife agencies until December 28 to comment, more than a month past the original November 25 deadline[1, 2].

The draft is a rewrite of the CWD Program Standards, the guidance document that tells states and herd owners how to meet the Herd Certification Program and interstate movement rules in 9 CFR parts 55 and 81[2, 3]. The standards were last revised in 2019[2, 5]. APHIS posted the new version October 26 under docket APHIS-2026-0563[2]. The extension notice is on public inspection and is scheduled for Federal Register publication November 23[1].

What the draft standards change

Trace and quarantine periods. The regulations define a CWD-exposed animal as one exposed to a positive animal or contaminated premises within the previous 5 years[6]. The draft keeps that window for elk and other species but, as an exercise of what it calls regulatory discretion based on changes in scientific knowledge, applies 3 years for mule deer and 4 years for white-tailed deer[3]. The same split governs which animals count as exposed in an investigation, and how long a quarantine runs before release[3]. A herd with more than one species must use the longest species period[3].

State animal health officials, with concurrence of the APHIS Cervid Health Team, may shorten a quarantine based on the herd’s genetics, testing history and epidemiology[3]. Herds holding only white-tailed or mule deer can also seek earlier release through whole-herd antemortem testing and genotyping under an approved protocol[3].

APHIS’s own summary puts the expected result plainly: “fewer trace herds will need to be quarantined, and some may be eligible to be released from quarantine earlier—helping more producers qualify for interstate movement”[4].

Predictive genetics. A new appendix sets out how herds should use genomically estimated breeding values (GEBVs) to breed for lower CWD susceptibility[3]. It names -0.056 as the maximum GEBV score from which to start breeding, tells owners in herds with no known CWD to remove animals above that score “as quickly as practicable,” and calls for GEBV testing of all fawns[3]. The draft is candid about the cost: “Effectively implementing a predictive genetics strategy may require the removal of many animals,” and improvement may take several generations[3]. Owners generally pay for GEBV testing themselves, though the draft says some states may have cooperative-agreement funding[3].

Hunt facilities. The 2019 standards let states move exposed animals onto a positive, quarantined terminal hunting facility if all cervids there are harvested within 90 days[5]. The draft extends that to 120 days[3]. It also lets the Cervid Health Team approve moving cervids to quarantined positive hunt facilities between contiguous states when both State Animal Health Officials concur, with the origin herd’s quarantine running another 5 years unless the animals test not-detected by rectal biopsy within 30 days before the move[3].

Missed samples. The current standards cut a herd’s status by a set amount per missed or unusable sample, scaled to the herd’s annual removal rate[5]. The draft instead sets a 95% target for valid mortality testing and cuts status by six months for every percentage point below it[3]. Its worked example: a Year 4 herd at 93% loses a year and drops to the start of Year 3[3].

How does CWD indemnity change for deer and elk herds?

The money itself does not change. Federal indemnity is 95% of appraised value and cannot exceed $3,000 per animal, a limit set in 9 CFR 55.2[7]. The draft restates that cap[3].

What changes is who gets paid first. The 2019 standards ranked requests on eight factors, starting with fund availability and herd size and preferring breeding herds over hunt preserves[5]. The draft ranks CWD-positive herds first, then source herds, then exposed herds[3]. Within those groups, cost comes first: APHIS may fund “multiple small high and medium priority herds” ahead of “a single large, high priority herd”[3]. Next come certified and compliant herds that can document all breeding animals below the GEBV cutoff, then enrolled herds meeting the same test, then certified herds without that documentation, then enrolled herds, and last non-compliant or non-program herds[3]. Distance from CWD in wild deer also counts, and a herd must be more than 50 miles from a wild detection for that to outrank program enrollment[3].

Two exclusions stand out. Hunt preserves are “rarely indemnified” unless a herd poses a significant risk to an unaffected population or is needed for research, and premises that were depopulated and restocked once are not eligible again[3]. Owners can also request indemnity for positive animals and for exposed animals scoring above -0.056, provided they follow a genetics-based herd plan and stay in full program compliance[3].

The draft adds a written appeal process. An owner who disputes the table valuation has 15 days to give notice and 30 days after that to submit an independent appraisal, which a panel of APHIS staff reviews[3].

APHIS frames this as a shift in approach. “A key part of this modernization is shifting away from whole‑herd depopulation as the default approach,” its announcement says, adding that savings as indemnity needs fall will go to research on diagnostics and genetics[4].

In the pens and on the hunt ranch

For white-tailed deer breeders, the shorter quarantine is the headline. A trace-out herd that would have sat for five years under the 2019 guidance could clear in four, or sooner by whole-herd testing[3, 5]. Elk ranchers see no change in the timeline[3].

The genetics provisions carry real costs for breeders. A herd built for other traits may have many animals above the -0.056 cutoff, and the draft ties both indemnity priority and some quarantine decisions to GEBV scores[3]. Hunt facility operators gain 30 more days to harvest animals received from quarantined herds but sit near the bottom of the indemnity list[3, 5].

In the docket: state wildlife agencies and deer farmers

The early comments split along familiar lines. The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources asked for 90 days, saying the 30-day window “falls exactly during cervid hunting seasons and chronic wasting disease surveillance when staff do not have the time to review the revised program standards”[8]. The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources asked for at least 60 days, warning that otherwise state wildlife officials would not have time to review the document or comment meaningfully[9]. APHIS’s extension notice cites only the need to give interested persons more time[1].

Producers who have commented so far mostly back the direction. Silverhorn Ranch wrote that “These are science based changes that will help support my industry”[11]. A commenter identified as Wide and High Whitetails supported “the relaxing of the standards” but objected to relying only on GEBVs, arguing that genotype-based resistance has more research behind it[10]. The draft does use the codon 96 genotype as well, for example in deciding where a purchased white-tailed deer was infected and which pen mates to remove[3].

What to watch

  • December 28, 2026: Comments close on docket APHIS-2026-0563[1].
  • After comments: If APHIS judges that no substantive changes are needed, the revisions become final without another Federal Register document[2]. Only substantive changes trigger a new notice with a final version[2]. APHIS has not published a target date.
  • Recordkeeping: APHIS says it plans a national recordkeeping system for herd inventories, submissions and certification status, with no timeline given[4].