APHIS proposes keeping industry horse inspectors, drops scar rule and orders pads pulled on class winners
A November 13 proposal would withdraw what remains of the 2024 Horse Protection rule, keep designated qualified persons under new conflict-of-interest limits and add a two-veterinarian check with on-site appeals. Comments close December 14.
Under a proposal the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) published November 13, the Tennessee Walking Horse or racking horse that ties first in its class would have its pads removed at the post-show check so an inspector can look for pressure shoeing[1]. That requirement sits inside a larger reversal: APHIS would withdraw what is left of its May 2024 Horse Protection rule, keep the industry-licensed inspectors that rule was written to replace, and delete the decades-old scar rule[1]. Comments are due December 14, 2026[1].
What APHIS is proposing
The proposal, Docket No. APHIS-2026-0067, does three things at once[1].
It clears out the vacated 2024 provisions. On January 31, 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, ruling in a suit brought by the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association, held that the 2024 rule’s bans on action devices, pads and substances exceeded APHIS’s authority under the Horse Protection Act[1]. The court also threw out the rule’s replacement for the scar rule and its appeal and re-inspection procedures as lacking adequate due process[1]. APHIS would now strike those sections from the regulations[1].
It withdraws everything the court left standing. The court upheld the 2024 rule’s replacement of designated qualified persons (DQPs), the inspectors that show management appoints, with APHIS-trained Horse Protection Inspectors (HPIs)[1]. APHIS proposes to withdraw that piece anyway, along with new reporting rules, a farrier requirement and other surviving provisions[1]. The agency says it did not anticipate the extent of the vacatur or “the unworkable patchwork of provisions” left behind, that it did not foresee a second lawsuit, and that Congress did not raise the program’s budget to pay for HPIs[1].
It rewrites the current rules in 9 CFR part 11. APHIS describes this as modernizing inspection procedures “for the first time in 34 years”[1]. The main changes:
- DQP licensing. Licenses would run 5 years, so a DQP would repeat the 14-hour candidate training each cycle, plus 4 hours of continuing education a year[1]. APHIS would supply experienced equine veterinarians to teach 10 of the 14 hours[1]. Candidates would apprentice at four covered events instead of two[1]. Horse industry organization (HIO) DQP programs would be certified for 10 years rather than indefinitely[1].
- Conflicts of interest. A DQP could not have had, in the preceding 5 years, any personal, professional or financial interest in showing, selling or auctioning walking or racking horses, including owning, training, riding or caring for them, directly or through immediate family or business ties[1]. A DQP could not inspect horses owned or trained by family, an employer or an officer of the DQP’s own HIO[1].
- More inspectors at larger shows. Management would have to appoint at least two DQPs when more than 100 horses are entered, down from 150[1].
- Masking agents and testing. The rule would prohibit substances that hide soring, naming sedatives and topical numbing agents, and DQP programs would cover pastern swabs and blood sampling[1].
- Scar rule removed. APHIS would delete it without a replacement while it studies whether training with action devices causes the skin thickening seen on walking horse pasterns[1].
How APHIS inspections and appeals would change
For inspections APHIS itself conducts, two APHIS veterinarians would each examine the horse and would have to concur on the finding before APHIS notifies the person responsible for the horse[1]. The person responsible for the horse could then appeal on the spot to an Appeals Official, a veterinarian with at least 5 years of direct equine practice, hired as a special government employee and barred from horse-protection conflicts of interest[1]. APHIS would appoint up to four of them on staggered schedules across a season[1].
A horse found sore would be disqualified only from the class in which it was inspected, not the whole event[1]. Equipment problems that can be fixed on the spot could be corrected and the horse reinspected for the same class[1].
Why does APHIS say the HPI program could not work?
The agency’s own numbers carry most of the argument. The 2024 rule estimated it would need 59 HPIs but expected only about 30 applications a year[1]. APHIS accepted 67 applications from veterinarians, which it calls less than 1% of potentially qualified vets, and says it still could not cover more than 200 covered events a year[1]. It had estimated its own costs under the 2024 rule could rise by up to $3.2 million a year, while Horse Protection funding stayed flat in fiscal 2024, 2025 and 2026[1].
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) puts that funding at about $3.5 million a year over those three years, up from less than $1 million a year from fiscal 2010 through 2019[3]. APHIS staffing on the program peaked at about 21 full-time equivalents in fiscal 2023 and fell to about 16 in fiscal 2024, according to CRS[3].
APHIS also cites a directive in the House Appropriations Committee report on the fiscal 2026 agriculture bill telling the agency “to withdraw the final rule and work with the industry to eliminate soring using objective, science-based protocols”[1]. The same report said the 2024 rule underestimated its effect on “the 20,000 jobs supported by the Tennessee Walking Horse industry”[1].
In the barn and the show ring
The people this reaches are owners, trainers and exhibitors of walking and racking horses, show and sale managers, and the HIOs that run DQP programs. APHIS estimates about 80 DQPs would need training under the new provisions and about 12 HIOs could apply to keep their certifications[1]. It expects most affected entities to be small businesses and says it lacks the data to price the changes for HIOs; it asks commenters to supply it[1].
Padded performance horses face the most direct change. APHIS says it remains concerned about “disproportionately high rates of noncompliances” in padded classes[1]. Under the proposal a DQP would remove pads on the first-place horse at minimum, once per day for a horse that wins more than one class that day, and on the next horse up if the winner is disqualified and the class re-tied[1]. APHIS considered random pad pulls and digital radiography instead and asks for comment on both[1].
Masking-agent testing matters because APHIS reports that swabs it collected in fiscal 2017 through 2023 tested positive for analgesic or anesthetic agents, mainly benzocaine and lidocaine, about 37% of the time on average, with performance horses making up 90.4% of positives[1].
The scar rule’s removal cuts the other way. APHIS expects more horses could be found sore after showing, because otherwise legal action devices can aggravate existing conditions[1].
The gap between inspectors is part of the record. CRS, citing APHIS data, lists noncompliance rates for performance horses of 1.5% to 4.3% at DQP-only inspections in fiscal 2017 through 2022, against 9.3% to 39.7% in APHIS’s own inspections[3]. In fiscal 2026, APHIS told CRS, it attended 49 covered events, DQPs inspected 25,567 horses and management disqualified 359[3]. The statute itself requires show management to disqualify any horse that is sore or that a management-appointed inspector or USDA flags as sore[2].
On the Hill and in court
Humane World for Animals and its advocacy arm oppose keeping DQPs. When APHIS delayed the 2024 rule to December 31, 2026, the third such delay, the group’s Chelsea Perez said USDA “must end this group’s ability to monitor itself”[5]. The groups back the Prevent All Soring Tactics Act, H.R. 1684[5]. CRS lists that bill and the Protecting Horses from Soring Act, H.R. 1675, as proposals to prohibit action devices and stacked shoes and raise penalties[3].
In April, Humane World sued USDA over its pullback of the scar rule, the no-showback policy and the disqualification process, and over the 2024 rule’s suspension[6]. The walking horse breed association’s account of the case says it was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia and seeks reinstatement of prior enforcement and implementation of the 2024 rule[7]. That account adds that USDA’s moves followed a Texas ruling and a separate preliminary injunction that “required the agency to reassess how certain rules are applied”[7]. The injunction came in August 2025 in a second Texas case, which challenged the no-showback policy, the scar rule and disqualification procedures[1].
When APHIS announced the December 31 date in January, Deputy Administrator Bernadette Juarez said partial implementation “would result in an unworkable patchwork of rules”[4].
What to watch before December 31
Comments close December 14, 2026[1]. On December 31, the surviving provisions of the 2024 rule are set to take effect[1]. CRS wrote in August that from that date DQPs would no longer be authorized to conduct routine inspections and that APHIS had paused HPI training while it revised the curriculum[3]. The November proposal mentions that date only in recounting the delays and does not set a new one[1]. Whether APHIS delays them a fourth time, and who inspects horses at the first shows of 2027 if it does not, is not answered in the docket.