Skip to the news

Federal farm & food policy for producers, lenders and agribusiness

Commodity Hill

Federal agriculture and food policy, from the committee room to the field.

Livestock

Forest Service proposes 35% surcharge on leased cattle, lease-based permits and a beginning-rancher priority; comments due Dec. 14

The first full rewrite of national forest grazing rules since 1977 would let ranchers qualify for term permits on leased land and livestock, add a BLM-style surcharge on leased livestock, and codify 21-day season shifts for drought and fire.

Thirty-five percent. That is the share of the gap between the federal grazing fee and a state’s private pasture rent that national forest permittees would pay, per animal unit month (AUM), for grazing livestock they lease from someone else, under a proposed rewrite of Forest Service grazing rules filed for public inspection November 10[1]. The same proposal would, for the first time in regulation, let a rancher qualify for a term grazing permit on leased base property and leased cattle[1]. Comments are due December 14[2].

What the proposed rule changes

The proposal rewrites subparts A, B and C of 36 CFR part 222, the rules for grazing on about 96 million acres of Forest Service allotments[1]. The Forest Service says the permit rules in subpart A “have not been comprehensively revised since 1977,” and the fee rules in subpart C have stood largely unchanged since 1979[1]. The agency administers nearly 5,550 grazing permits[4].

Most of the rewrite moves policy that already sits in Forest Service Manual 2200 and Handbook 2209.13 into regulation, and the agency says no substantive change is intended except where it says so[1]. The changes it does call out:

  • Qualifying for a permit. An applicant would have to “own or lease” base property and the livestock to be permitted[1]. Base property would cover private land with ranch facilities, private land that can grow crops or forage for the herd, and stockwater rights held under state law[1].
  • Six exceptions to the ownership rule. They cover successional base property deals, mentor and mentee arrangements, successional livestock purchases, extended livestock purchases for beginning ranchers, split ownership between family entities, and a single conservation-easement ranch qualifying several permit holders[1]. A mentee or beginning rancher could run up to 50% of the mentor’s permitted numbers[1]. Family members’ livestock could also make up as much as 50% of the permitted number, if the permit holder reports their number, ownership and brands each year[1].
  • Beginning-rancher priority. When a forest offers new grazing capacity by prospectus, qualified beginning ranchers, mentees and small business ranchers would get priority, replacing an order that favored BLM permittees whose ranges needed adjustment[1]. The rule defines a beginning rancher as a permittee’s child or grandchild, or anyone who has not owned or been an officer of a farm or ranch business for 10 or more years[1].
  • Season shifts. A permittee could ask in writing to turn out up to 21 days before the permit’s start date or stay up to 21 days past the end date[1].
  • Non-use. Temporary non-use for personal convenience, meaning grazing less than 90% of permitted numbers, could run up to 4 consecutive years, up from 3, but no more than 4 years in any 10-year rolling period[1].
  • Drought and fire. A new disturbance framework in sections 222.2(e) and 222.5(d) would set out temporary changes such as fewer head, a shorter season, moved supplement sites or targeted grazing, with documentation of duration, pastures and end criteria[1].
  • Other permits. Livestock use permits for research, leased sires or targeted grazing could run up to 5 years instead of 1[1].

The proposal also replaces fixed permit caps with authority to deny a transfer that would concentrate permits in one family or group, or split an allotment into permits too small to run[1]. In the Eastern States, it drops the 10% bid deposit for competitive allotments and adds limited liability companies as allowed bidders[1].

How would the leased-livestock surcharge work?

The fee formula itself does not change. The proposal keeps the $1.23 base value, the indexes for forage rent, beef prices and prices paid, the $1.35 floor and the 25% annual cap, and moves national grasslands into the same section as the 16 Western States[1]. The 2026 fee under that formula is $1.69 per AUM[4].

The surcharge rides on top of it. On Western forests and grasslands, a permittee grazing livestock owned by someone else would pay 35% of the difference between the current year’s federal fee and the prior year’s private grazing lease rate for the state, as set by the National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS)[1]. In the Eastern States the surcharge would be 35% of the noncompetitive Eastern fee for the subregion[1]. It would be billed per AUM and paid before turnout[1].

The Forest Service gives three reasons: to recover its added administrative cost, to “capture a portion of the larger profit associated with pasturing livestock,” and to match the Bureau of Land Management (BLM)[1]. BLM’s rule at 43 CFR 4130.8-1(f) already uses the same 35% formula[3]. The agency adds that the surcharge “does not prohibit leasing, but may provide incentive to maintain owned livestock” that know the allotment[1].

What that means per head depends on the state. Using the 2026 federal fee and the 2025 private rates published by two land-grant extension services, this report’s arithmetic gives[4, 8, 9]:

State 2025 private rate per month 2026 federal fee Gap 35% surcharge per AUM
South Dakota $36.50 $1.69 $34.81 $12.18
Montana $29.50 $1.69 $27.81 $9.73

For 100 leased cows on a 4-month season, or 400 AUMs, that would add about $4,873 in South Dakota and $3,893 in Montana to a bill that comes to $676 at the base fee[4, 8, 9]. The 17-state average rate SDSU reported for 2025 was $23.70[8].

In the field: who pays and who doesn’t

Cow-calf and sheep operators running only their own stock see no surcharge. Calves under 6 months that are the progeny of fee-paid cows stay free[1]. The exposure falls on permittees who fill permitted numbers with livestock owned by others.

The preamble says exemptions from the surcharge would cover documented mentees, beginning ranchers, permittee successors, immediate or extended family members, and operators receiving relief because of drought, fire or other natural causes[1]. That list appears in the proposed Eastern-state sections, 222.52(d) and 222.53(i)[1]. The proposed Western section, 222.50(d), states the surcharge and the 35% formula but does not list the exemptions[1]. The current BLM rule exempts livestock owned by permittees’ sons and daughters[3].

For beginning ranchers, the bigger change is the qualifying rules. The Forest Service concedes that under the old priority order, “Nearly all grant priority process decisions were issued to existing Forest Service permittees” and rarely reached new applicants[1]. Lease-based qualification and the prospectus priority are the agency’s answer, though new capacity only goes to prospectus after existing permittees with resource problems or improvement investments are considered[1].

The agency puts no dollar figure on costs, which it calls modest. It labels the rule deregulatory under Executive Order 14192 and says most permittees are small entities but that it does not expect a significant economic effect on a substantial number of them[1]. A Paperwork Reduction Act notice on new forms, including surcharge-exemption attestations, is still to come[1].

On the Hill and across the fence line

The proposal is the Forest Service half of a joint effort. Under a March 2026 memorandum of understanding with BLM, the two agencies agreed to prioritize vacant and closed allotments, streamline permitting and expand targeted grazing, and BLM staff helped draft this rule from January to June[1]. BLM published its own grazing rewrite on May 12, with comments closed July 13[5].

Reaction to the BLM version shows where the lines fall. Ranchers in Wyoming and Nevada told WyoFile they wanted the added flexibility and less paperwork, and the Western Landowners Alliance backed the changes[7]. WildEarth Guardians and Western Watersheds Project told WyoFile the rules would favor the grazing industry on public land and that most allotments get little environmental review[7]. In Oregon, the Oregon Natural Desert Association objected to narrowing who counts as an interested member of the public, while the Public Lands Council, the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association and the American Sheep Industry Association filed comments supporting the BLM proposal, according to OPB[6].

Environmental review is where the two rules overlap most with the critics’ complaints. OPB reported that BLM treats its rewrite as eligible for a categorical exclusion, which the Oregon group disputed[6]. The Forest Service takes the same position on its own proposal, saying site-specific grazing decisions would still get review under the National Environmental Policy Act[1]. It would also make allotment management plans optional, relying on annual operating instructions where a full plan is not needed[1]. No congressional vote is required; the agency cites existing authority back to the Organic Act of 1897[1].

What to watch

Comments on RIN 0596-AD75 are due December 14 at regulations.gov[2]. The Forest Service asked specifically whether it has matched BLM closely enough and where it could go further, and it invited comment on small-entity effects[1]. The next fee-year bill under either agency’s formula starts March 1, 2027[1, 4]. Whether the final Western surcharge text carries the exemption list the preamble promises is open until a final rule is published.